Cheapest priced copy (Wilds of Eldraine Tokens): $0.35 at Card Kingdom, near mint, their price list as of Sat, 31 Oct 2026 07:41:31 GMT.

Nightmare

Creature — Nightmare Horse · */* · Common · Theros Beyond Death Tokens · #12

Flying (This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with flying or reach.)

Nightmare's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Swamps you control.

Legal inCommanderPioneerModernLegacyVintage

Not legal inBrawlStandardPauper

31 printings · $0.35 to $3299.99 at Card Kingdom

Set	Number	Rarity	Card Kingdom	Foil
Tenth Edition	164	Rare	$0.49	—
Tenth Edition	164★	Rare	—	$2.99
Unlimited Edition	119	Rare	$79.99	—
30th Anniversary Edition	115	Rare	$34.99	—
30th Anniversary Edition	412	Rare	$179.99	—
Revised Edition	120	Rare	$5.49	—
Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border	150	Rare	—	—
Fourth Edition	150	Rare	$2.29	—
Fifth Edition	184	Rare	$0.59	—
Classic Sixth Edition	146	Rare	$1.29	—
Seventh Edition	150	Rare	$0.79	—
Seventh Edition	150★	Rare	—	$199.99
Eighth Edition	150	Rare	$0.49	—
Eighth Edition	150★	Rare	—	$10.99
Ninth Edition	150	Rare	$0.49	—
Ninth Edition	150★	Rare	—	$6.99
Collectors' Edition	119	Rare	$17.99	—
Intl. Collectors' Edition	119	Rare	$21.99Out of stock	—
Foreign Black Border	120	Rare	—	—
Limited Edition Alpha	118	Rare	$3299.99	—
Limited Edition Beta	119	Rare	$799.99Out of stock	—
Magic 2010	107	Rare	$0.49	$0.49
Magic 2014	108	Rare	$0.49	$0.49
Magic 2015	276	Rare	$0.59	—
Magic Origins	282	Rare	$0.49	—
The List	W17-17	Rare	$0.49	—
Summer Magic / Edgar	120	Rare	—	—
Theros Beyond Death Tokens	12	Common	$1.49	$1.49
Wilds of Eldraine Tokens	6	Common	$0.35	$0.49
Welcome Deck 2016	8	Rare	$0.49	—
Welcome Deck 2017	17	Rare	$0.49	—